Tried & Tiered Logo

Our Playbook.

This is our method for honest reviews. A transparent, hands-on process designed to cut through the hype and deliver a definitive verdict. Here's how every product is judged.

Phase 1: The Hunt

We monitor the hype. Social media, new releases, and your requests. Then, we buy the most talked-about products anonymously, at full retail price. No press samples. No special treatment.

Phase 2: The Hands-On Review

Every product becomes part of our daily life. We unbox it, set it up, and use it consistently and intensively to judge it against our four core pillars:

Build Quality & Finish
Core Functionality
Everyday Usability (UX)
Value for Money

Phase 3: The Roundtable

The practical experience tells part of the story; our team debate tells the rest. Our reviewers convene to share their hands-on findings. We compare notes, debate pros and cons, and consolidate our thoughts.

Phase 4: The Verdict

After the roundtable, a product is assigned its final, unshakeable tier. This is our definitive judgment, and it is law.

S
Legendary:Best in class. A game-changer. The benchmark against which all others are measured.
A
Excellent:A fantastic product with minor, forgivable flaws. An enthusiastic recommendation.
B
Solid:Gets the job done reliably, but won't blow you away. A safe, sensible choice.
C
Mediocre:Functional, but deeply compromised in one or more areas. You can do better.
F
Fail:An absolute failure. A product that shouldn't exist. We bought it so you never have to.

Our Unbreakable Rules

Allegiance to the User

Our loyalty is to you, our reader, not to the brands we review.

Experience is Our Compass

Our opinions are formed by real-world use, not just spec sheets.

The Tier List is Final

Our rankings are a definitive statement, free from outside influence.

Now, See the Results.

The process is transparent. The verdicts are in. Explore the lists.

Explore The Tier Lists